Life is full of moments worth celebrating. The moment you decide to spend forever with someone. The day you say your vows in front of the people you love most. Welcoming a baby into the world. Watching your kid walk across the stage at graduation. Finally clocking out for retirement, or toasting decades of marriage.
Some of those moments deserve something you can hold onto, a daily reminder that you’ll wear for years and maybe pass down someday. For a whole lot of people in the Treasure Valley, that’s where Simmons Fine Jewelry comes in.
Jay Simmons opened Simmons Fine Jewelry in 1989. For 37 years, it’s been where Treasure Valley couples have picked out their engagement rings, and then come back decades later to celebrate an anniversary or life milestone.
Jay says he’s in business to help people celebrate. “We just happen to do it with jewelry.”

Jay Simmons, credit Simmons Fine Jewelry
The beginning
Jay grew up in Rupert, Idaho. When he was 14, his parents divorced, and his mom was left raising five kids. She sold Avon, and one of her customers happened to be a local jeweler. She told him that if he ever needed help, she had a 14-year-old son who would work for him.
“He gave me a job for a dollar an hour,” said Jay. “Of course he gave me raises, but I learned how to engrave and size rings and take watches apart and then clean them and put them back together.”

Jay in front of that first store, credit Simmons Fine Jewelry
He worked at that store all through junior high and high school. After graduation, he moved to Boise and he’s worked in a jewelry store ever since.
By 28, Jay knew a lot of customers and a lot of vendors, and he was ready to open his own store. He and his wife, Stacey, went to the bank for a loan. The bank said no. So Stacey’s dad loaned them $100,000, and about $10,000 of it went straight toward putting the sign on the building. Vendors Jay had worked with for years gave him jewelry on consignment to fill the cases.
That first Simmons Fine Jewelry was a 1,400-square-foot shop near Boise Towne Square, right about where the PetSmart is now. Those early days were long ones. Jay would leave for work at 7 or 8 in the morning and get home around 10 at night.
“I’ve worn all the hats. The janitor hat, the marketing hat, the salesman hat, the owner hat,” said Jay.


Moving to Meridian
After 17 years in that shop, Jay had built a reputation with customers and vendors for luxury-level jewelry and service to match. He’d become known for his integrity and honesty, which Jay says is what eventually got the big-name brands to take him seriously. With that reputation behind him, Jay moved Simmons to its current home on North Olive Avenue in Meridian. The store is now about 8,000 square feet.
The bigger store changed what Simmons could be. Luxury brands started paying attention. Today, brands come to Jay asking to be in his store, and he turns some of them away because, in his words, he can’t be everything to everyone.

It picks you
Simmons is a high-end jewelry store, and Jay is upfront about it. Nearly everything is 18-karat gold or platinum, and the gemstones are so vivid that customers sometimes ask if they’re real. Many of the brands are ones you’d once have found at Neiman Marcus or Saks, and Jay says Simmons is the only store in Idaho that carries a lot of them.
At Simmons you can find Hearts on Fire, natural diamonds with a cut so precise that Jay says less than 1% of the world’s diamonds qualify. There’s Mikimoto, the company whose founder created the first cultured pearl, with Akoya and South Sea strands that each carry a tiny gold M. There’s John Hardy, made by hand in Bali. And there’s Picchiotti from Italy, with rubies, emeralds, and sapphires, plus rings and bracelets with titanium springs inside so they stretch.
Other brands you’ll find at Simmons include Oscar Heyman, JB Star, Roberto Coin, and Marco Bicego, along with watches from TAG Heuer, Grand Seiko, and Oris.
For Jay, it’s important to have jewelry in the cases that people can see and try on. A photo in a catalog just doesn’t land the same way as seeing and feeling a ring on your hand. And there’s an old saying he swears by: you don’t really pick a stone, it picks you. Jay has seen it happen time and time again, with his customers and for himself. That’s why he wants people to fall for it in person.
“I don’t buy jewelry just to think about reselling it. I buy it because it talks to me,” said Jay.
He’s honest about price, too.
“I am not the cheapest in town. I don’t want to be. I want to be the best,” said Jay.
Most people wear their jewelry every day, and every time they look at it, they think of the person who gave it to them. As Jay put it, “The cool thing about jewelry is it lasts for generations.”

Made in-house
One of the coolest parts of my visit to Simmons was seeing what goes on below the showroom.
This is where Simmons makes custom jewelry. A ring gets designed on the computer, a 3D printer grows a wax model, and the wax gets cast into gold right there in the building. When I was there, one jeweler was clipping freshly cast rings, while another was using a laser welder under a microscope to rebuild worn prongs on a ring.
Three jewelers work down there, including one who’s been with Simmons for 26 years. Because they make jewelry in-house, they can also repair it, and everything they sell comes with a warranty. Jay sees being someone’s jeweler as a lifelong relationship.
The wedding ring store, and so much more
That’s one of the store’s taglines, and Jay says it’s usually how the story goes. A couple comes in for wedding rings. Then life happens: a house, kids, college, new furniture. 20 years later, they remember where they got their rings and come back for an anniversary band or a new pair of earrings.
Jay loves helping the people who walk in nervous and unsure. He’ll ask them about the day they got engaged, and they’ll start telling the story. Then he helps them find a piece that says the same thing, all these years later.
“If you want a special experience, it’s here,” said Jay.
The people
After nearly four decades, you might expect Jay to talk mostly about diamonds. But that isn’t the case.
“Through the years I’ve become more and more passionate about what I do. I still love incredible gemstones and diamonds. I love watches. But with all that being said, I love the people,” said Jay.
Simmons has 15 employees, and one has been with Jay for more than 30 years. Every Friday, Jay cooks breakfast for the whole team before their weekly meeting. He’s been doing it for almost 20 years.

What’s next
Jay has seen plenty of independent jewelry stores close because there was no one to hand them to. Simmons won’t be one of them.
Jay and Stacey have four children and 16 grandchildren. Their son Blake has been working at the store for more than 20 years. He grew up in it, and today he manages the entire operation. Over the years, he has been part of countless milestones for both the business and its customers. Blake plans to take over Simmons Fine Jewelry one day. He has a deep passion for the legacy his dad built, and a vision for rooting Simmons even deeper within the Treasure Valley community. Who knows, maybe one of the grandkids will follow in Blake’s footsteps.
Until then, Jay is still showing up, still falling for new stones, and still walking people case to case to find the perfect piece for whatever moment they’re celebrating.
“I have an amazing store,” he told me. “I never take it for granted.”

Visit Simmons
You can visit Simmons Fine Jewelry at 1220 N. Olive Ave. in Meridian. They are open Tuesday through Friday, 10 am to 5 pm, and Saturday, 11 am to 5 pm.
You can also browse online at simmonsfinejewelry.com, but nothing beats the experience you’ll find in store.
Simmons also has a handful of in-store events throughout the year. If you are planning for an upcoming engagement or dreaming of the big day, Simmons is hosting The Engagement Edit on Saturday, November 21 from 11 am to 5 pm. For one day only, you can sip complimentary wine tastings from Gem 73 and be the first to see new arrivals and shop special pricing on select engagement rings.
Whether you’re shopping for an engagement ring, a holiday gift, or something to mark a milestone, Simmons is here to help you celebrate.

Credit Simmons Fine Jewelry.
Thanks for reading!
With love from Boise,
Marissa
This story is sponsored by Simmons Fine Jewelry.
If you’re interested in getting your product, service, or event in front of 26k Boise locals → book a call
